LATEST SCAM ALERT: “Researchers Created a Phonics Program With ‘Dramatic’ Results.”
Spoiler alert: no, they didn’t.

Education Week recently reported about a “new” phonics program with “dramatic” results. Sadly, it’s yet another “Science of Reading” scam.
Why?
The program may be “new” but the curriculum is ESSENTIALLY THE SAME as every other phonics curriculum. They are using intensive tutoring in order to increase student scores on tests that measure phonics skills. BUT PHONICS SKILLS DO NOT EQUATE WITH READING ABILITY.
For some reason this same story pops up every 3-4 years with another program from another company claiming “dramatic” results or a “miracle.” All these stories tell exactly the same story as if everyone has forgotten the last story where some kind of intensive phonics training / tutoring was used to increase student scores. (Here is a blog post we posted about the fake Mississippi miracle https://blog.readingkingdom.com/how-mississippi-gamed-its-national-reading-test-scores-to-produce-miracle-gains/)
From the Education Week article: “A new study has found evidence of big gains in students’ reading ability from using one specific phonics program—and suggests that consistent implementation is key to getting the strongest results. When kindergarten and 1st grade teachers in one Florida district used the program for a year, their students grew at a much faster rate than similar students in other classrooms in the district that continued business-as-usual reading instruction. Teachers who followed the program more closely saw better results than those who didn’t teach lessons in the recommended sequence, or with all of the listed steps…”
[NOW HERE IS THE IMPORTANT PART OF THE ARTICLE THAT IS BURIED AT THE END]
“Using statistical models, the researchers compared kids who received the program to kids who didn’t, but shared similar demographic characteristics. The kindergartners and 1st graders who completed the lessons scored higher on DIBELS, an assessment of word-reading ability and oral-reading fluency.”
Over the years there have countless programs touting increases in Dibels scores – increases that have NEVER correlated to improvements in actual reading ability. Dibels is such a ridiculous test that they even test children on how to sound out nonsense words (they laughably call it “Nonsense Word Fluency” which is reading gibberish). This would be like testing a child’s ability to play the piano by how well they can randomly hit the keys on a piano keyboard.
In a couple of years when the kids who are now in first grade show no improvement once they are tested using tests meant to determine actual reading and comprehension ability, this latest “dramatic” result will end up exactly where all the other ones have gone – into the memory hole of reading failure that characterizes American literacy instruction.

Reading Kingdom is an online K-3 reading program that uses a new “phonics-plus” model to teach students to read and write at a 3rd grade level with comprehension. Sign up for a complimentary Reading Kingdom trial (or any of our other products) here.
We also have a program for students on the autism spectrum and others who face unique learning challenges called ASD Reading. Sign up for a complimentary trial of ASD Reading.
State & Charter school funding is available! Look for your program and begin using your education funds today!
Want to help a child in need learn to read? Try shopping at our Amazon affiliate store where a portion of every sale goes towards teaching kids the life-changing skill of reading.

